The Canada-USA border closure (for the land border) will be extended for an extra month, until November 21st. Once again, it seemed fairly obvious that it would be extended. It makes sense. But in this update, let’s highlight an important detail about the American political system.
Here’s everything you need to know about the coronavirus-related Canada-USA border closure.
Canada-USA border closure (October 19th update)
The Canada-USA land border closed on March 21st for one month, and the measure had been extended by one month 6 times, all the way to October 21st. I will let you read the details below in case you hadn’t already.
Now it’s been officially confirmed that the Canada-USA border closure will once again be extended by one month, until November 21st, the 7th extension.
And keep in mind that even though the US presidential election takes place on the Tuesday following the first Monday in November (not the first Tuesday in November as many believe), win or lose, Trump will remain President until January 20th, 2021. So those who believe a Biden win would lead to a border reopening in November might be disappointed.
I don’t think many of you are really surprised about this new extension. Unlike many countries that had taken control of the coronavirus situation at some point, the US has been hit pretty hard all along, so this was to be expected and it’s logical.
Especially with Canada being hit by the second wave now.
You can still travel to the US by air, for those of you who want to… but just because you can doesn’t mean you necessarily should. Two completely separate things. For any trip (even a roadtrip), we encourage you to consider the 15 factors in our guide about whether you should travel or not (with major update coming soon).
We’ll also soon have a detailed guide about which countries we’re allowed to visit (which obviously includes Greece and Turkey where we just traveled to ourselves this summer) for those who are ready to travel like us (and like the many travelers who write to us daily to know the safest destinations). Sign up for free to get everything. And of course, you can travel to many Canadian provinces already (by car or by plane).
What is illogical
All the data shows that the coronavirus situation in the USA is worse than in Canada. That’s factual. But what is just as factual is that the situation in other countries is better than in Canada (for example, about half of the world’s countries have fewer active cases per capita than Canada).
Based on those facts, there are two things that are illogical.
First, by having no gradation for risk levels and no list of safest countries, the Canadian government is in effect saying that going to Iceland is as risky as going to the US. Which is absolutely and objectively absurd, of course.
- 75 active coronavirus cases
- a requirement to get 2 negative tests to get in
- managed the crisis in an exemplary manner since the start, based on every metric
By putting every country at the same risk level, Canada is not only ignoring the science and the facts… but Canada is also leaving those who want to travel on their own. Instead of at least helping them choose the safest countries, since it’s undeniable that going to Iceland (and many other countries) is less risky than the US… and even than Canada too.
For those who are interested:
- the European Union has established a list of ≈ 15 safest countries
- the United Kingdom has eliminated the quarantine for ≈ 40 countries
- France has re-established risk levels by country for their advisories
- even the US has re-established risk levels by country for their advisories
Which leads us to the second illogical thing.
We’ll talk about it in greater detail this weekend in a post about our own experience entering Canada and quarantining, but once again, based on the science, the facts, and the evidence, there is absolutely nothing to support that Canada is the #1 country in the world in terms of the coronavirus situation.
Yet, most Canadians can travel within Canada without quarantining after. But going to a country where the situation is better than here (again: based on the facts) requires a quarantine. There’s just nothing rational or logical about that.
Maybe there should only be 5 countries considered safe (we can make our own rules based on the data), but in all cases: there should be a list. There’s no data to support that traveling everywhere is riskier than traveling within Canada. Some countries undeniably have a lower infection rate, have strict entry measures, and the risk on board a plane is “infinitesimally small” according to the Minister of Transport himself.
Of course, the quarantine should be maintained for countries where things aren’t going well. But for countries where they’re going better than here? It’s hard to justify rationally.
Especially considering the very deficient monitoring of that quarantine; to be followed soon.
Predicting when the Canada-USA border closure could end
Many experts are pretty confident that the Canada-USA border will not even reopen this year at all.
Our government has not given any indication about the future, whether it’s about this, the restriction on all foreigners who want to enter Canada, or the mandatory quarantine period when entering. Those last two measures theoretically expire on October 31st, so we’ll know more in the next 2 weeks.
But it’s crazy when you think about it: our common border with the US had essentially never been closed in history, and it might actually be closed for nearly a full year (or more). And it’s definitely plausible.
It’s extremely hard to predict anything in this context though, so we’ll have to wait and see. Flytrippers will keep you updated on all developments.
What the border closure extension means for travelers
Obviously, this doesn’t mean you can’t enter Canada if you’re Canadian (Canadian border restrictions don’t apply to Canadians). Also, this means you can’t enter the USA by car, but it does not mean you can’t enter the US at all—see next section.
In short, this measure closes our land border and restricts Americans from entering Canada by any means. That’s it.
This is just one of Canada’s 4 travel-related measures.
Travel restrictions that keep you from traveling
Of course, you are definitely allowed to travel internationally even today (plenty of flights are available and many countries have reopened to Canadians). Travel restrictions and the travel advisory are completely separate things, as we explained in greater detail in our post on the 3 myths about border restrictions.
Just to be clear, many countries are open and they are the only ones that determine if you CAN travel or not, Canada has nothing to do with that. Those are the facts, and they’re important to understand since all of these concepts will likely remain a consideration for some time, even when some measures will have been lifted.
So understanding how the measures all work will help you, no matter when it is you’ll be ready to travel.
If you do want to think about traveling, at least do it safely and responsibly—we’ll be here to help you do so. You should thoroughly consider the 15 important factors in our ultimate guide to make sure you are comfortable with all the current risks in your personal situation.
Factors to consider that don’t formally keep you from traveling
There are 2 main factors that our Canadian government controls that impact if you SHOULD travel or not, namely the quarantine upon return and the travel advisory that voids some travel insurance policies (but now some Canadian insurers include COVID-19 in their medical travel insurance coverage).
There are many other elements to consider that are in our guide, but I’ll just highlight two.
Air Canada’s summer schedule for international flights announced in May was very ambitious, so we were optimistic that things would get back to normal for travelers more quickly than they have, but that hasn’t been the case.
It’s not impossible that the quarantine requirement would be lifted for safe countries on October 31st, to make international travel more accessible in the fall, but our optimism has sure been dampened significantly for those who don’t want to go into a 14-day quarantine upon return.
As for Canada’s travel advisory (that does not prohibit you from traveling contrary to the widespread myth), it could be lifted before that quarantine requirement ends or before our own borders reopen to international travelers, which would help Canadians choose the safest destinations among the countries that have reopened to Canadians. The advisory currently has no known end date.
You can read more analysis in our post about Canada’s travel-related measures.
But it’s just too soon to know when things will change. That’s what we keep telling you: we can only wait and hope. International travel will require being more flexible and easygoing for a while, as we explained at the end of our post about Canadians being on the list of 15 nationalities allowed to enter the European Union.
Canada’s entry restrictions
Canada has also extended its entry restrictions (border closure) for non-American international travelers until October 31st.
That is irrelevant to Canadians of course, but… when Canada’s government will let in international travelers, logically it will also stop recommending that we don’t travel (at least for some low-risk destinations instead of the current blanket advisory).
The opposite would make absolutely no sense.
It’s not impossible for our travel restrictions to be lifted before November 21st for countries less affected by the coronavirus than the US. When Canada closed its borders in March, at first Americans were exempted (for just one day, but still) so maybe we’ll see the opposite this time.
Land border vs. air border
As a reminder, for us Canadians, the Canada-USA border closure applies only to the land border. There is absolutely no restriction on entering the US by plane, and there never was.
Like everything else in life, just because you can doesn’t mean you should. There are plenty of good reasons not to go to the US, so no need to resort to falsehoods like saying it’s not allowed. It definitely isn’t, that’s objective. Whether you should is subjective.
You can read our detailed post about how Canadians are allowed to fly into the USA.
Exceptions to our border restrictions
Of course, there are the standard exceptions for essential travel.
But in June, Canada changed its entry restrictions (not just with the US—all border restrictions) to let some non-Canadians in, specifically those who are immediate family members of Canadian citizens and permanent residents.
Some media outlets have stated this was an exception “for Canadians” but that is false.
At the risk of repeating myself, it’s important to understand how border restrictions work if you want to be better equipped to travel when it’s the time to do so: Canadians have never been banned from entering Canada. It’s not possible for “Canadians to get exempted” since Canadians are already exempted from Canadian entry restrictions (and always have been).
This new exception is for foreign nationals to enter to reunite with their family, as long as they don’t have COVID-19 symptoms. They still are required to go into quarantine for 14 days no matter what.
You can read who is eligible for this new exception here.
Previous border closure extensions
Here is the history of the Canada-USA border closure due to the coronavirus:
- On September 15th, the border closure was extended to October 21st
- On August 14th, the border closure was extended to September 21st
- In July, the border closure was extended to August 21st
- In June, the border closure was extended to July 21st
- In May, the border closure was extended to June 21st
- In April, the border closure was extended to May 21st
- In March, the border closure was announced from March 21st to April 21st
Initial border closure news on March 18th
In another incredible (and rapid) development, the Canada–USA border is expected to be closed soon. We here at Flytrippers had learned this from a source last night before major outlets published it, but since it was unconfirmed, we did not want to share information that wasn’t official either.
It still isn’t 100% official as of 12:30 AM Wednesday, but credible media outlets have now published this, so let’s say it’s almost sure to happen.
How did we know 2 hours before CNN posted this late tonight? Well, someone who is currently stuck abroad, an acquaintance of Flytrippers’ other cofounder Kevin, shared with us what the Canadian embassy had told him. They said finding a return flight that stopped in the US was not an option to return to Canada.
This was odd since, as we speak, there is no restriction on Canadians entering the US (as long as you haven’t been to Europe, like our source who is in a completely different region).
This led us to believe the Canadian embassy knew something was happening about the Canada–USA entry restrictions, although we were a bit skeptical that the embassy would be at liberty to share that with random travelers before it is made official.
But sure enough, they did, because this is happening. Air restrictions ended up not being a thing, so they didn’t have all the information, but they definitely had some. That is why it is very important to contact the emergency consular services if you’re stuck abroad, as we mentioned in our general tips on getting home).
Border closure basics
So to summarize:
From the very beginning of this crisis up until this Monday (March 16th), there was absolutely no restriction on entering Canada.
Monday, the Canadian government announced that the border would be closed to foreigners, except Americans.
And then the very next day, the embassy was telling Canadians not to return via the US, and a Trump administration official has told CNN that the Canada–USA border will be closed after all.
Wow, this situation is really evolving more quickly than anything we’ve ever seen.
Now, what does this mean? Well, apparently, the border will be closed to non-essential travel, meaning there would be some exceptions (as of yet undefined). So it’s a little less restrictive than Canada’s previous restriction on all other nationalities announced Monday. And this one is different since it is bilateral and not unilateral; in other words, it’s a mutual agreement.
Many have wondered what took Canada so long to close its border. Some say that managing the vital relationship with the US played a part, while others definitely think otherwise since Americans were first excluded anyway. Whatever the case, soon it’ll be closing to Americans too.
Of course, this does not mean that the Canadian border is closed for Canadians who want to return home. We explained that in our article about the facts related to the Canadian government’s travel advisory issued before the border closing announcement: you live here; they can’t decide not to let you in. The exception is if you have symptoms, and if you’re interested, even that is apparently unconstitutional, according to some experts. Some are already mounting a legal challenge to remove that condition.
But as we also said, when the border is closed, there is no demand for flights, and those will eventually almost all be canceled, so you won’t be able to return that way. That’s the issue most people stuck abroad are facing as we speak, since airlines are cutting flights left and right for many reasons. One of the main ones is to try and preserve cash flow to mitigate what will likely turn out to be the worst crisis the aviation sector has faced in, well, maybe forever.
The Canada–USA border closing is not just problematic for those stuck in the USA, but rather for all those stuck everywhere. The US, being the biggest aviation market in the world, was the best place to fly to in order to get out of all the other countries (except Europe) and then get to Canada, with a lot more flight options that go to Canada directly.
At least, if you’re in the US, as a last resort, you might be able to return home overland, but at the rate things are going, who knows if domestic travel restrictions could be put in place in the US. This is not impossible at this stage; the US President alluded to it himself. If movement between states is restricted, even returning overland would be complicated. The many Canadian snowbirds still in the US should take that into account.
Having spent 10 days in the US as the pandemic started, my perception is that things will get a whole lot worse there before they get any better. In that article, I shared my experience entering Canada by plane on Monday, and the measures I was subjected to. These have been strongly criticized in the past week.
Finally, yesterday my uncle and aunt asked me for help finding them a way back from Saint-Martin in the Caribbean, where they spend a few winter months. Flights being canceled are one thing, but the entry restrictions by other countries are also making it very complex to find a place to transit to. They definitely aren’t the only ones who want to come back from various parts of the globe.
Want to get more content to stay up-to-date with travel restrictions?
Sign up for our free newsletter
The Canada-USA border closure is going to persist until at least November 21st.
What do you think of the Canada-USA border closure? Tell us in the comments below.
Explore awesome destinations: travel inspiration
Learn pro tricks: travel tips
Discover free travel: travel rewards
Featured image: border in Blaine, WA (photo credit: dherrera_96)
Advertiser Disclosure: In the interest of transparency, Flytrippers may receive a commission on links featured in this post, at no cost to you. Thank you for using our links to support us for free, we appreciate it! You allow us to keep finding the best travel deals for free and to keep offering interesting content for free. Since we care deeply about our mission to help travelers and our reputation and credibility prevail over everything, we will NEVER recommend a product or service that we do not believe in or that we do not use ourselves, and we will never give any third-party any control whatsoever on our content. For more information on our advertiser disclosure, click here.