Cheap flights from New York City to Reykjavik, Iceland from $271!

Roundtrip flight New York - Reykjavik for $271

Flytrippers Deals
Aug 14, 2025
Deals from New York City

This deal is probably expired! Sign up for our newsletter here to never miss out again, or you can check today's deals here.

This post may contain affiliate links that could provide you with exclusive deals and could provide a small commission to Flytrippers at absolutely no cost to you. Thank you for using our links to support us, to allow us to provide valuable travel deals and content for free, and to help us accomplish our mission of helping you travel for less. We will never recommend a product or service if we don't believe in it and no third party ever gets any control over our content. Third parties, including financial institutions, are not responsible for maintaining the content on this site. See our terms & conditions for more details.

REYKJAVIK, Iceland 🇮🇸

$271 (or 27,100 simple points)
	Normal average price: $452 (or 45,200 simple points)
	Roundtrip, all taxes/fees included
	FROM: EWR - Newark Liberty International Airport JFK - New York JFK International Airport
	TO: KEF - Reykjavik Keflavik Int'l Airport
	See all available dates

$271

(or 27,100 simple points)

Normal average price: $452 (or 45,200 simple points)

Roundtrip, all taxes/fees included

FROM:
EWR - Newark Liberty International Airport
JFK - New York JFK International Airport

TO: KEF - Reykjavik Keflavik Int'l Airport

See all available dates

🔎 Pro tip: Always check if the flight price is the same on the airline's direct website before booking!

DATES

Deals expire quickly; act fast! Click here for more details.

Oct 6 - Oct 21	15d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 7 - Oct 21	14d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 8 - Oct 21	13d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 11 - Nov 1	21d	Sat - Sat	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 11 - Nov 4	24d	Sat - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 12 - Nov 1	20d	Sun - Sat	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 12 - Nov 4	23d	Sun - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 13 - Oct 28	15d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 13 - Nov 4	22d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 14 - Oct 28	14d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 14 - Nov 4	21d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 15 - Oct 28	13d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 15 - Nov 4	20d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 20 - Oct 29	9d	Mon - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 20 - Nov 4	15d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 21 - Oct 29	8d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 21 - Nov 4	14d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 21 - Nov 5	15d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 21 - Nov 6	16d	Tue - Thu	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 21 - Nov 12	22d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 22 - Nov 4	13d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 22 - Nov 5	14d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 22 - Nov 6	15d	Wed - Thu	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 22 - Nov 12	21d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 23 - Nov 5	13d	Thu - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 23 - Nov 6	14d	Thu - Thu	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 23 - Nov 12	20d	Thu - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 26 - Nov 15	20d	Sun - Sat	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 27 - Nov 15	19d	Mon - Sat	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 27 - Nov 18	22d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 28 - Nov 12	15d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 28 - Nov 15	18d	Tue - Sat	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 28 - Nov 18	21d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 28 - Nov 19	22d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 29 - Nov 12	14d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 29 - Nov 18	20d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 29 - Nov 19	21d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 7 - Oct 21	14d	Tue - Tue	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 7 - Oct 22	15d	Tue - Wed	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 7 - Oct 28	21d	Tue - Tue	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 7 - Oct 29	22d	Tue - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 11 - Oct 21	10d	Sat - Tue	JFK-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 11 - Oct 22	11d	Sat - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 11 - Nov 1	21d	Sat - Sat	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 21 - Oct 29	8d	Tue - Wed	JFK-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 21 - Nov 4	14d	Tue - Tue	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 21 - Nov 12	22d	Tue - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 22 - Oct 31	9d	Wed - Fri	JFK-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 22 - Nov 5	14d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 22 - Nov 12	21d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 22 - Nov 18	27d	Wed - Tue	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 26 - Nov 4	9d	Sun - Tue	JFK-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Oct 28 - Nov 12	15d	Tue - Wed	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 28 - Nov 18	21d	Tue - Tue	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 28 - Nov 22	25d	Tue - Sat	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 29 - Nov 12	14d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Oct 29 - Nov 19	21d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Oct 29 - Nov 26	28d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Or redeem points of the more simple type			27,100 points instead of $271		Learn more >
Or redeem points of the more simple type (27,100 points instead of $271)				Details >

Nov 11 - Dec 3	22d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 11 - Dec 5	24d	Tue - Fri	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 12 - Dec 3	21d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 12 - Dec 5	23d	Wed - Fri	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 13 - Dec 3	20d	Thu - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 13 - Dec 5	22d	Thu - Fri	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 17 - Dec 9	22d	Mon - Tue	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 18 - Dec 3	15d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 18 - Dec 9	21d	Tue - Tue	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 18 - Dec 10	22d	Tue - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 19 - Dec 3	14d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 19 - Dec 9	20d	Wed - Tue	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 19 - Dec 10	21d	Wed - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 20 - Dec 3	13d	Thu - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 20 - Dec 10	20d	Thu - Wed	EWR-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 12 - Nov 27	15d	Wed - Thu	JFK-KEF	$271		Details >	$271 >
Nov 12 - Dec 3	21d	Wed - Wed	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Nov 16 - Dec 11	25d	Sun - Thu	JFK-KEF	$273		Details >	$273 >
Nov 18 - Dec 4	16d	Tue - Thu	JFK-KEF	$272		Details >	$272 >
Or redeem points of the more simple type			27,100 points instead of $271		Learn more >
Or redeem points of the more simple type (27,100 points instead of $271)				Details >

Might not be a deal, but at least find the lowest price for your specific dates

Check out our flight search tips and more tools here

DIR Non-stop flight

Dates for weekend getaway

Very limited dates at this price

Flight at an even more discounted price than usual!

Flytrippers logo in a flag Lowest price we have ever seen!

ULCC Involves at least 1 ultra low-cost carrier (ULCC)

No Suitcase Involves at least 1 airline without free regular carry-on bags

V Calendar Dates available during a popular vacation period

Self-transfer that implies a few pecularities

Deals powered by Skyscanner, Momondo, Kiwi & Kayak

Accommodation Options

Check out today's best deals from New York City

See all other deals from New York City

Our latest travel content

Travel Tips
	RV relocation deals at $1/day Mar 19, 2026
	How I got $1000 in free hotels and meals during my delayed flight (and ≈ $200 in rewards for future free travel) Mar 11, 2026
	My experience applying for the UK Electronic Travel Authorization (UK ETA) Jan 25, 2026

Travel Inspiration
	Introduction: My current trip to Asia (yet another very peculiar one) Mar 27, 2026
	Top 5 must-see places in Ireland that are NOT Dublin Mar 17, 2026
	4 tips for a trip to Ireland, a beautiful place to raise a glass (repeatedly) Mar 17, 2026

Follow Flytrippers on Facebook

Flytrippers New York City

Follow Flytrippers on Twitter

Follow @FlytrippersNYC

Featured image:

Other images associated with this deal: Main page: Pixabay, Social media: Pixabay

Share this deal to help us help more people travel for less:

REYKJAVIK, Iceland 🇮🇸

DATES

Accommodation Options

Sign up for our free newsletter

Check out today's best deals from New York City

Our latest travel content

Travel Tips

RV relocation deals at $1/day

How I got $1000 in free hotels and meals during my delayed flight (and ≈ $200 in rewards for future free travel)

My experience applying for the UK Electronic Travel Authorization (UK ETA)

Travel Inspiration

Introduction: My current trip to Asia (yet another very peculiar one)

Top 5 must-see places in Ireland that are NOT Dublin

4 tips for a trip to Ireland, a beautiful place to raise a glass (repeatedly)

Follow Flytrippers on Facebook

Follow Flytrippers on Twitter